Hallmark+ Renews 'Finding Mr. Christmas'

The competition series will return for Season 2.

December 23, 2024

Hallmark+ announced today that Finding Mr. Christmas has been renewed for a second season. The news comes less than two weeks after the streaming competition series crowned its first winner.

"It's nearly impossible to create a piece of entertainment that truly breaks through in this overcrowded market, let alone to make one that wears its heart on its sleeve while being deeply entertaining," said David Sefanou, Head of Unscripted Programming, Hallmark Media, "Finding Mr. Christmas is that show, and we can't wait to do it again."

"My hope for season one was that we would create something that would stand out in the reality TV landscape – a show that is competitive yet genuinely heartwarming and uplifting," said co-creator Ben Roy. "I am so proud of what our incredible cast and crew have achieved. The positive response from fans has been incredible. We can't wait for the challenge to make season two even more heartfelt, more entertaining, and somehow... even more handsome."

Hosted by Jonathan Bennett, the show features ten aspiring actors competing in a variety of entertaining challenges to be crowned Hallmark's next leading man and take home the title of "Mr. Christmas." Lead judge Melissa Peterman is joined by special guest judges as these men are put to the test to determine who has the most talent, heart, authenticity and charisma to be the next Hallmark superstar. At the finale, the winner receives a special leading role in one of this year's Countdown to Christmas movies on Hallmark Channel.

Look for Season 2 of Finding Mr. Christmas in 2025.